Home » , , » The Uncomfortable Truth & Harsh Reality Of UNCERTAINTY in Medicine

The Uncomfortable Truth & Harsh Reality Of UNCERTAINTY in Medicine

Posted by Jerry De Luca on Thursday, September 9, 2021


Everyone would love total certainty when it comes to physical and mental health. Sadly in a fallen world this is hard to come by. Uncertainty is uncomfortable and can cause anxiety. No matter how much it hurts, seeking after and applying basic hard truths are a wiser option in the long run. The devious “certainty” claimed by alternative medicine practitioners may sound like good news now, but catastrophic in a short time. Some people ignore hard science discovered by double-blind, randomized clinical trials and instead choose to get duped by their smooth-talking, snake-oil peddling, charismatic “doctor”.

Harriet Hall, MD, a retired Air Force physician and flight surgeon, writes and educates about pseudoscientific and alternative medicine. In this excerpt she provides an excellent overview of how conventional medical doctors have to deal with the prevalent and unavoidable uncertainties in medical care.

“We tend to think of medicine as science, but it’s not a science like astronomy or physics. Good medicine is based on science, but it’s an applied science. Treatments are based on evidence, but that means medical advice will change if better evidence comes along. Some people see the fact that medicine keeps changing its mind as a reason to distrust medical advice. But that’s not a defect; it’s a strength. It shows that medicine is responsive to reality.

“Uncertainty is ubiquitous in medicine. Memory is unreliable. Patients’ reports of symptoms may not be accurate. Physical exams can miss things, and anatomy is variable. For instance, in situs inversus, the organs are on the “wrong” side of the body. Lab tests are subject to many types of error, from failure to calibrate instruments to simple clerical errors. And normal lab values are a fiction based on testing a lot of people and calling the middle 95 percent of the bell curve “normal.” Imaging studies can be unreliable; remember the MRI study that seemed to show what a dead salmon was thinking?

“The predictions of science can be very accurate, but what about patients with a terminal disease who ask the doctor how long they have to live? Testimonials for alternative medicines often start with ‘The doctor said I only six months to live, and I’m still alive three years later thanks to X’ (where X is some random bogus remedy). Doctors’ predictions are often wrong, and patients may misremember or hear what they expected to hear rather than what the doctor actually said. Doctors who say ‘six months’ can’t really know if that is accurate. At best, it is only a guess based on the recorded survival of similar patients with the same disease. A median survival of six months doesn’t mean that everyone will suddenly drop dead six months later. It means that some individuals will die before six months and some won’t die until after six months—sometimes long after. And possibly never: spontaneous remissions have occurred even in the most deadly diseases. Spontaneous remissions are not understood and can’t be predicted.

“One of my favorite diagnoses is IBTHOOM (It Beats the Hell Out of Me). If doctors are honest, they will admit that they can’t explain everything. I often had to tell patients I didn’t know what was wrong with them. I only knew what was not wrong with them because testing had ruled out those diagnoses. It would not be reasonable to do every possible test a laboratory could offer or to do exploratory surgery or brain biopsies with no idea what we are looking for. I tried to persuade my patients that more testing at this point would be useless or even counterproductive. A wild goose chase might only turn up random false positive results and end up doing more harm than good. I reassured them that if they got worse, we could then do directed testing as indicated for their new symptoms. Meanwhile, we could concentrate on finding ways to help them cope with their present situation. Most patients were happy to accept that watchful waiting was the best option and were open to efforts aimed at mitigation.

“Doctors regularly face uncertainty. They constantly have to make decisions based on inadequate information. They have to prescribe an antibiotic before the cultures have identified the pathogen. They may get it wrong, but they have to do something. Doing nothing is not an option; without treatment, the patient will die. When unexpected bleeding occurs during surgery, the surgeon has to take swift action. If he ‘does a Hamlet’ and stops too long to think about it, the patient will bleed out and die.

“Doctors have to make educated guesses based on many factors. They have to consider what diseases are prevalent in their community, whether the patient is a reliable historian or has a habit of hysterically rating their pain as fifteen on a scale of ten. Doctors have to judge probabilities and decide whether the test results should change their minds. Is the post-test probability of the diagnosis greater than the pre-test probability? Is there even enough reliable information available to base estimates of probability on? Doctors are constantly having to make informed guesses based on the best currently available evidence, which is all too often unreliable or insufficient.

“(There) are degrees of certainty. Doctors are not ivory tower philosophers or scientists. They have to act. They deal in practical applications of science and try to choose the least uncertain options. Their educated guesses can be very accurate. They developed safe and effective COVID-19 vaccines in record time. They changed HIV/AIDS from a death sentence to a chronic disease that is treatable and doesn’t significantly reduce life expectancy. They treat diabetes effectively with diet, drugs, and insulin to reduce the number of deaths and complications. They can’t explain everything or treat everything effectively, but they save lives.

“Real medicine may be full of uncertainty, but if it is grounded in reality. It works. Contrast reality-based medicine with the other kind. The other kind (we might call it belief-based medicine) never admits to any uncertainty. It deals in bogus certainties. You will never hear a practitioner of so-called alternative medicine express any uncertainty or doubt. Chiropractors are certain their patients have subluxations. They blithely ignore the fact that different chiropractors find subluxations in different places. And they are happy to disregard the 2009 study by chiropractors themselves that concluded that there is no supportive evidence for the subluxation construct and that subluxation has no valid clinical applicability. Homeopaths are certain the water in their dilute remedies can remember an original ingredient that is no longer there, and they are certain that homeopathy works. If it doesn’t, they find an excuse to blame the patient (for not following directions precisely or for doing something that supposedly interfered with it working).

“Acupuncturists are certain they can accurately locate meridians and acupoints despite evidence to the contrary, and they truly believe sticking needles in those points somehow magically relieves symptoms and improves health. Nurses who practice therapeutic touch are certain they are manipulating the human energy field despite evidence that they can’t detect that imaginary field when their view of the patient is obstructed. All of these practitioners fail to realize that their patients may just be responding to attention, relaxation, and the provider’s confidence—and they may be experiencing a placebo response.

“We all crave certainty. Perhaps that’s why so many people are inclined to listen to quacks who claim to know the one true cause of all disease rather than to real doctors who are honest enough to say they don’t know what is wrong. Uncertainty is a fact of life, and we must learn to accept it and deal with it appropriately.”


Living with Uncertainty      https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/living-with-uncertainty/                                                                    

Related Posts

How To Avoid Bad Medical Advice: A Basic Guideline http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2016/05/how-to-avoid-bad-medical-advice-basic.html

Integrative Medicine Sprinkles Fairy Dust Over Medical Treatments http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2018/08/integrative-medicine-sprinkles-fairy.html

How To Think Correctly When Receiving A Troubling Diagnosis  https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2020/04/how-to-think-correctly-when-receiving.html

Cancer Quackery Playbook: 9 Devious Methods  https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2020/06/cancer-quackery-playbook-9-devious.html

21st Century Snake-Oil: Stem Cell Clinics Preying on the Desperate https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2018/11/21st-century-snake-oil-stem-cell.html

New Hope for an Alzheimer’s Cure  https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2019/01/new-hope-for-alzheimers-cure.html

The Latest Science on Back Pain https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2019/10/the-latest-science-on-back-pain.html

15 Devious Tactics & Lies of Complimentary & Alternative Medicine https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2021/09/15-devious-tactics-lies-of.html

Esoteric Medicine: New Vibrant Name For The Same Old Snake-Oil https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2020/08/esoteric-medicine-new-vibrant-name-for.html

Next Level Snake-Oil: Women Duped By Goop  http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2017/09/next-level-snake-oil-women-duped-by-goop.html

8 Basic Reasons People Fall For Alternative Medicine  https://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2019/07/8-basic-reasons-people-fall-for.html

9 Basic Ways Shameless Health Gurus Dupe Their Followers http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2018/02/9-basic-ways-shameless-health-gurus.html

13 Basic Ways Alternative Medicine Takes Advantage Of Patients  http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2018/01/13-basic-ways-alternative-medicine.html

17 Concise Reasons Why Homeopathy is a Fraud  http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2013/10/17-concise-reasons-why-homeopathy-is.html

17 Concise Reasons Why Natural News Is A Fraud  http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2017/07/17-concise-reasons-why-natural-news-is.html

13 Concise Reasons Why Mercola Is A Fraud   http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2017/01/13-concise-reasons-why-mercola-is-fraud_27.html

9 Devious Ways Alternative Medicine “Doctors” Deceive Their Patients  http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2015/01/9-reasons-why-some-alternative-medicine.html    

9 Brazen Reasons To Shun Naturopathic “Medicine” http://www.mybestbuddymedia.com/2016/02/9-brazen-reasons-to-shun-naturopathic.html

Photo: https://knowledge.insead.edu/blog/insead-blog/embracing-uncertainty-for-innovation-4776  

Jerry De Luca is a Christian freelance writer who loves perusing dozens of interesting and informative publications. When he finds any useful info he summarizes it, taking the main points, and creates a (hopefully) helpful blog post.


Post a Comment

Feel free to leave any comments...